When a child loses a tooth, there’s almost always excitement in the air—a small gap in their smile, a coin under the pillow, and the enduring magic of the Tooth Fairy. It feels timeless, yet the tooth fairy history is surprisingly modern.
It feels like a timeless tradition, yet the Tooth Fairy is a surprisingly modern invention. Her origins trace through centuries of superstition, folklore, and cultural evolution, revealing how a simple childhood ritual became one of the most beloved traditions in Western culture.
Ancient Beliefs About Baby Teeth
Long before the Tooth Fairy, societies around the world had rituals surrounding lost teeth. In many ancient cultures, baby teeth were thought to hold spiritual power. Losing them meant more than growing up. It also meant vulnerability to bad luck or evil spirits.
In Viking culture, children’s teeth were considered good luck charms. Warriors would wear them into battle, believing they offered protection. Meanwhile, in medieval Europe, people often buried or burned baby teeth to prevent witches from using them in spells. The act of destroying or hiding the tooth was meant to protect the child from harm.
Other regions developed different customs. In Japan and Korea, children traditionally thrust their lower teeth upward (toward the roof) and their upper teeth downward (toward the ground) to encourage straight growth of their adult teeth. In Spain and Latin America, the story eventually centered on a small mouse—Ratoncito Pérez—who collected children’s teeth and left gifts behind, foreshadowing the Tooth Fairy’s role.
Check out Why Do We Yawn When We See Others Yawn? for another look at curious human behavior.
The Arrival of the Tooth Fairy
The modern Tooth Fairy, as we know her today, first appeared in the United States in the early 1900s. While the exact origin is debated, the concept likely merged old European “tooth mouse” tales with American ideals of generosity and imagination.
One of the earliest written references appeared in a 1908 issue of The Chicago Daily Tribune, which suggested that parents could ease children’s fear of losing teeth by introducing a “good fairy” who would exchange the tooth for money. The idea quickly caught on, especially as 20th-century America embraced new children’s myths like Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny.
By the 1920s and 1930s, the Tooth Fairy had become a household figure. The Great Depression may have even fueled her popularity. While times were tough, a coin under the pillow represented both reward and comfort, reinforcing hope and the idea that small acts of magic could brighten difficult days.
The Fairy Takes Flight in Popular Culture
The Tooth Fairy didn’t fully solidify her image until the postwar boom of the 1940s and 1950s, when American pop culture began celebrating childhood innocence and imagination. Children’s books, cartoons, and radio programs began featuring the fairy as a tiny, benevolent figure with wings and a wand, modeled after classic European fairies.
In 1949, the first dedicated play, The Tooth Fairy, was written for children’s theater, helping standardize the character in the public imagination. Soon after, the tradition became widespread across English-speaking countries. By the mid-20th century, the Tooth Fairy had become a permanent resident of bedtime folklore.
Unlike Santa or the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy’s visits are personal and unpredictable. She arrives not on a fixed date but whenever a milestone occurs. That individuality made her special to children, turning each tooth loss into a private moment of wonder.
Love folklore that sticks? Read The Strange Origins of Everyday Phrases We Still Use.
Global Variations and Modern Twists
While the winged fairy dominates in North America, other cultures have maintained their own traditions. In France and Spain, the story of La Petite Souris (the Little Mouse) remains popular, often coexisting with the fairy tale in modern households. In Mexico, Ratoncito Pérez continues to exchange teeth for coins or sweets, showing how folklore adapts across generations.
Today, the Tooth Fairy is bigger and busier than ever. Surveys show that the average “tooth payout” in the U.S. has risen dramatically over time, with inflation turning the once-modest nickel into a few dollars or more. Tooth Fairy apps, pillows, and letter-writing kits have turned the simple ritual into a miniature celebration of childhood milestones.
Some families even add their own creative touches: glitter “fairy dust” trails, tiny notes, or photo evidence of her visit. In a digital age, the Tooth Fairy has found new ways to stay relevant. This adaptation is proof that wonder still has a place alongside technology.
Why the Tradition Endures
At its heart, the Tooth Fairy ritual isn’t about the money; it’s about the magic of transition. Losing a baby tooth is one of the first visible signs of growing up, and the fairy transforms what could be a frightening experience into a joyful one. The exchange under the pillow is symbolic: the child trades a small piece of the past for the promise of what’s to come.
Parents, too, find meaning in the ritual. It’s a brief, whimsical way to nurture imagination and mark the fleeting stages of childhood. Much like Santa Claus, the Tooth Fairy represents kindness, generosity, and belief in unseen good. It’s a comforting idea in any era.
See Why Do We Dream About People We Haven’t Seen in Years? for more on memory and nostalgia.
A Modern Myth with Ancient Roots
From Viking warriors to American bedrooms, the story of the Tooth Fairy is a patchwork of human imagination spanning centuries. It blends old fears, ancient customs, and modern magic into a single tradition that bridges the past and present.
While her exact origins may be cloudy, her purpose remains clear: to turn a small moment of change into one of celebration. And as long as children keep losing teeth, the Tooth Fairy will keep flying. This tradition is proof that even the smallest myths can have the longest lifespans.
