Why Do Humans Keep Pets (Even the Weird Ones)?

From dogs and cats to snakes, parrots, and tarantulas, humans have an enduring fascination with keeping animals as companions. Across cultures and history, we’ve welcomed creatures of all shapes and temperaments into our homes, and often our hearts. But why? 

What drives us to bond with species that share neither our language nor our instincts? The answer lies in a blend of evolutionary psychology of pets, emotional biology, and the universal human search for connection.

From Survival Partners to Emotional Allies

The earliest human-animal relationships were born from mutual benefit, not sentimentality. Tens of thousands of years ago, wolves began scavenging near human camps, and humans tolerated them because they helped with hunting and protection. Over generations, that partnership evolved into domestication, giving rise to dogs—the first true pets.

Cats followed, drawn to grain stores filled with rodents. Humans let them stay because they served a purpose. But as agriculture stabilized and survival became easier, the nature of companionship changed. Animals that once served functional roles began filling emotional ones.

This shift wasn’t accidental. It’s rooted in the brain. Studies show that interacting with animals releases oxytocin, the same hormone responsible for bonding between parents and children. Petting a dog or cat lowers blood pressure, reduces stress hormones like cortisol, and activates brain regions linked to empathy and pleasure. In other words, our brains reward us for caring about animals.

Curious how animal instincts help us? Check out Can Animals Sense Natural Disasters Before Humans Can?

The Evolutionary Roots of Companionship

From an evolutionary standpoint, keeping pets may have reinforced social skills that improved cooperation and survival. Humans who were more empathetic and nurturing—traits extended even toward animals—were also better at raising children, forming alliances, and building stable communities.

This theory, known as the social byproduct hypothesis, suggests that pet keeping is an extension of our parenting instincts. We project human emotions onto animals because our brains are wired to respond to big eyes, soft features, and small size. These are the same cues that trigger caregiving behavior toward infants.

That’s why creatures like puppies, kittens, and even baby reptiles can spark feelings of affection or protectiveness. Evolution trained us to love what looks vulnerable.

Why Even the “Weird” Pets Appeal

While dogs and cats dominate the pet world, many people form deep bonds with unconventional companions, such as snakes, lizards, rats, or exotic insects. Psychologists suggest that these relationships stem from a combination of curiosity, identity expression, and emotional regulation.

People who keep unusual pets often describe them as extensions of their individuality. They use pets as living symbols of uniqueness or fascination with the natural world. Others find comfort in the calm, predictable movements of reptiles or fish, whose slow, rhythmic movements can have a meditative effect.

Even “creepy” creatures like tarantulas or scorpions can elicit empathy once familiarity replaces fear. Studies in anthrozoology (the study of human-animal interaction) show that caring for any living being—even one without expressive features—can reduce loneliness and enhance a sense of purpose. The act of nurturing itself, not the species, creates emotional reward.

Love feline physics? Read Why Do Cats Always Land on Their Feet?

Pets and the Brain’s Reward System

Modern neuroscience reveals that pet ownership taps into the same reward circuitry that governs social relationships. When people look into their pet’s eyes, both species experience a rise in oxytocin, creating a mutual feedback loop that mirrors human bonding.

In fact, brain scans show that pet owners exhibit neural activity patterns similar to those seen when they think about loved ones. This explains why losing a pet can feel as devastating as losing a human friend. That’s because the emotional circuitry is nearly identical.

The pet relationship also provides consistent emotional regulation. Animals don’t judge, argue, or reject; they offer unconditional presence. For many people, pets provide stability amid the unpredictability of modern life. It serves as a grounding force that fulfills deep psychological needs for comfort and companionship.

Smell and memory shape bonds, too. See Why Do Some People Remember Smells More Vividly Than Faces?

Cultural Evolution and Symbolic Roles

Throughout history, pets have also served cultural and symbolic roles. Ancient Egyptians revered cats as sacred guardians, while Chinese emperors kept songbirds as emblems of grace. In the modern era, pets symbolize lifestyle, empathy, and social identity.

Urbanization has only strengthened this bond. As human relationships become increasingly digital and transient, pets offer a tangible, nonverbal connection and authentic companionship that transcends language and culture.

Even the act of caring for another living being fulfills a fundamental biological drive for purpose and nurture, one that evolution built into our species long before technology arrived.

The Modern Meaning of “Pet”

Today, pets are more than companions; they’re family. Surveys show that over 80% of pet owners consider their animals members of the household, celebrating birthdays, mourning losses, and even creating social media profiles for them.

This emotional elevation of pets reflects how deeply intertwined our biology and psychology have become with animal life. Whether we keep a goldfish for tranquility, a dog for loyalty, or a gecko for fascination, we’re answering the same ancient instinct: to connect, care, and belong.

Check out Why Do We Dream About People We Haven’t Seen in Years?) for more on the memory and dream connection.

A Shared Evolutionary Journey

Humans didn’t just domesticate animals; animals helped domesticate us by teaching empathy, patience, and interdependence. Our shared history has shaped both species into more social, cooperative beings.

So the next time you talk to your dog like a friend, or feed a lizard as carefully as you’d serve a child’s meal, remember: this behavior isn’t strange at all. It’s the culmination of thousands of years of shared evolution. It reveals the most human truth of all: that caring, in any form, makes us who we are.

Related Articles

Child with a missing front tooth, ready for a classic Tooth Fairy moment.
Read More
Aerial view of a multi-lane roundabout with a central fountain and cars navigating traffic.
Read More
Mobil gas station sign in Massachusetts showing fuel prices ending in 9/10 of a cent.
Read More